Musical Instruments

Bar designs and timelines

Today is the 10th anniversary of the inauguration of this blog. At the five-year mark, its main focus shifted from the history of looped fabric (hence the name Loopholes.blog) to that of musical instruments. The autoharp soon took a dominant position among them, with articles examining it from various perspectives, and ever-increasing attention paid to its use in Irish traditional music.

The next post in the queue will discuss how the autoharp found its way into pub sessions across the island during the 1960s. I had initially intended to celebrate today’s milestone with it, but the preceding post triggered a discussion of unanticipated extent. It considered the late-19th-century innovations that led to the autoharp in the form now widely recognized as such, but ended without agreement on the order of their appearance.

I therefore decided to review that timeline in more explicit terms before segueing into the new topic. As it happens, an autoharp of a design patented by the central figure in the present post turned up in a Scottish pub 70 years before the outset of the chronicle planned for the next one. So the anniversary toast will be raised at a pub, after all!

The origin of the autoharp is often seen as a bilateral battle for priority over key innovations between Karl August Gütter and Charles Frederick Zimmermann (examined in an earlier post). However, the transatlantic and intra-European competition over rights to the manufacture and sale of such instruments had more than two central participants. A few of their names are familiar but others are not, and the broader story of their interaction is one of true Victorian intrigue.

The best known of the additional figures was Hermann Lindemann. Together with Gütter, he obtained the first German patent for a bar-based damping device, albeit in a mechanical implementation that differs significantly from the one now definitive of the autoharp. The damping bars are affixed on both ends to lever arms that hinge on the instrument’s upper and lower sides, as seen in this drawing from the patent.

Patent drawing

This mechanism is intended to accommodate a variable number of bars, each of which adds a lever arm to the stack on either side of the instrument. For the aggregate device to be mechanically stable, those sides and the lever arms must all be parallel. It cannot be attached to an instrument with a curved upper bout.

As the tale of this patent was told in Germany, Gütter was the inventor and Lindemann the entrepreneur (designating himself as a “Merchant” in a later British patent). They applied for their joint patent (DE29930) on 20 May 1884. It was issued on 5 January 1885 and somewhere along the line Lindemann bought out Gütter’s stake in it. The first mention of that transaction is found in a museum catalog from 1912 and dates it to 1883, but their documented collaboration extended at least to the submission of the patent application.

An editorial notice in a mid-1890 issue of the Zeitschrift für Instrumentenbau (Journal of Instrument Making), cited fully below, tells us that “Lindemann’s Volkszither [made] its initial appearance in commerce just four years ago.” By then, he and Gütter had parted ways under what appear to have been acrimonious circumstances. This may explain the delay between the granting of their patent and Lindemann bringing the instrument to market as his own.

Gütter’s response to the surmised rift was to apply for a British patent (GB1884:8888) for the bar device patented in Germany. He could legitimately claim to be its “true and first inventor.” For good measure, he extended its applicability from a zither to the piano in the provisional specification of that patent, submitted on 4 September 1884.

The purpose of a provisional specification was to acquire a priority date for an invention that was otherwise only described tersely and without illustration. Gütter replaced the initial bar device with a fundamentally different one in the complete specification of the British patent, dated 11 March 1885. The basic mechanism claimed in it was indistinguishable from that of the exhibition model autoharps that Zimmermann put on public display in 1884, and also produced and sold commercially.

Lindemann followed suit by including the same bar design in an improvement patent linked to the earlier German one (DE40312: “Zusatz zum Patent No. 29930”). He applied for it on 17 January 1886, which was also the priority date, but it wasn’t issued until 10 August 1887. The sole claim in the parent document was for the hinged damping device. Notwithstanding the potpourri of alternate bar configurations and means for activating them in the drawings accompanying the improvement filing, it only made one actual claim — for a second damping device. The initial bar design appears in a single instance, shown frontally as the uppermost of the bars in Fig. 4, and laterally in Fig. 6.

Patent drawing

The one being added is seen most clearly in Fig. 5 and is of the now commonplace design. It can be compared directly with the following photograph of an autoharp with the less elaborate of Zimmermann’s exhibition designs in the collections of the Musikinstrumenten-Museum Markneukirchen, Germany (inv. no. 4491; detailed in the post about Zimmermann and Gütter linked to above), kindly provided by Mario Weller at the museum.

Zimmermann exhibition autoharp, MMM 4491
Photo: Frank Fickerlscherer-Faßl, Musikinstrumenten-Museum Markneukirchen.

The dates in the sequence of attested innovative events give Zimmermann unequivocal priority for this bar design. However, he never sought legal protection for it. Notwithstanding his emblazoning every autoharp that he subsequently produced with the number and date of his US patent (US257808), the rights this conferred were restricted to the lateral pull-bar action described and claimed in it.

Patent detail

By unilaterally asserting that the patent’s scope also covered the perpendicular push-bar action seen in the photo, and making instruments fitted with it publicly available, Zimmermann was ironically placing his modified bar design in the public domain. This left both Gütter and Lindemann free to use it on their instruments without the slightest taint of impropriety, but neither had any legal basis for patenting it. They camouflaged it successfully in their respective British and German patents, nonetheless, due to the way international prior art was weighed into the examination process in both countries at that time.

Digression: The drawing in Lindemann’s improvement patent clearly illustrates a perpendicular push-bar action. However, there is an anomalous arrow parallel to and above the bar in Fig. 5, explained as indicating that the bar “can be shifted lengthwise.” This is immediately contradicted by a correct description of the bars being pushed toward the strings for the production of chords. The arrow raises a strong suspicion of whoever wrote the patent description having seen Zimmermann’s earlier patent but not fully understood the difference between it and Lindemann’s claimed design. If so, Lindemann seems not to have spotted that inconsistency.

Lindemann then invoked the initial German patent no. 29930 when claiming monopoly rights to the production and sale in Germany of anything that might be seen as a zither with chord bars. He went on a litigious rampage defending his alleged monopoly, which is well documented in a series of exchanges in the German trade press. Gütter was an unnamed participant on the other side of the ensuing battle.

During its course, marketing bluster, innovations in the public domain, and statutory patent claims were thoroughly conflated. The upbeat to it is found in an editorial notice in the 21 August 1890 issue of the Zeitschrift für Instrumentenbau (Journal of Instrument Making), promoting Lindemann’s work.

Increasing demand was also evident for the Lindemann Volkszither, patented in several countries. This has enjoyed increasing popularity since its initial appearance in commerce just four years ago. Beyond the domestic market, it has conquered those of the entire north, including Denmark, Scandinavia, and Russia. It is now also being exported to countries overseas.

The scope of the international patent protection and marketing was demonstrably overstated, if not fabricated outright. If any similar freedom was taken with the date given for the instrument’s commercial introduction, it would surely have leaned toward the early side. This means that the first date that can reliably be set on the public availability of an autoharp with the design seen in the first illustration above was mid-1886.

This meshes with the January 1886 application date for Lindemann’s supplement to the German patent initially shared with Gütter. The full year between the granting of the first of them and the application for the second, taken with the unusually protracted processing time for the latter, reinforces the suspicion of underlying friction. Whatever the sequence of intervening events might have been, Lindemann sued a German manufacturer for infringing on his patent rights and advertised that action in the Zeitschrift für Instrumentenbau shortly (and doubtless not coincidentally) after the cited editorial promotion.

That announcement is dated 7 October 1890, and promised similar litigation against anyone else engaged in commercial trade in Germany with “the imitations of my patented Volkszither (German Imperial Patent No. 29930) that for some time have been marketed under the names Chorzither and Autoharp.” This triggered a full-blown trade war that Lindemann won as far as the German court decision went, but lost in the international marketplace.

The outcome was Lindemann licensing German patent no. 29930 to Julius Müller, who then included its number in widespread advertisements for an instrument of identical design to the one illustrated in the final specification of Gütter’s British patent and Zimmermann’s miniature autoharps. Since Gütter participated in Müller’s initiative there would have been no contention between them for priority to it, nor was that even chronologically possible.

In contrast, there can be no question about the characteristic exterior profile of that design having originated with either Gütter or Zimmermann and then been mirrored by the other. Neither of them made any claim to it in a patent specification. Whichever of them first made such an instrument available to the public thereby placed it in the public domain. If it were to be suggested that they had both somehow copied the same preexisting design, neither of them would have been eligible to patent it anyway.

The following comparison of the two models appears in several earlier posts but bears repeating once again.

Move the slider to compare the two images.

This situation parallels the one with Zimmermann’s revised bar device that he inadvertently made common property in 1884. If he placed it on the first of his miniature autoharps, Gütter — and Lindemann and Müller or anyone else — would have been free to use it without a hint of unfair business practice.

Nevertheless, the first attested appearance of the external profile was in the complete specification of Gütter’s British patent. It is dated 11 March 1885 but was sequestered from public view at the British Patent Office until the official announcement on 21 April 1885 of that specification having been accepted. The most rapid mode of conveying this information to Zimmermann in Philadelphia would have gotten it to him in early May.

By that time he had all but certainly released his miniature autoharps to the public. This leaves a second chronological impossibility of his having appropriated Gütter’s design. If Gütter had permitted prior public access to his claimed innovation, he would have risked the rejection of both the British application and his German patent.

Another upshot of the international patent squabble was that autoharps of American and German manufacture appeared side-by-side in Great Britain and Ireland, on a completely open market, driven by workshop quality rather than threats of legal action. Yet another earlier post cites numerous advertisements in the daily press there, alternately favoring the instruments produced by Müller or Zimmermann, available in a broad range of prices. This enabled the migration of what was initially an urban parlor novelty into rural contexts.

Newspapers also published reviews of well-received concert performances on the autoharp. The first reported such event took place in the Scottish town of Kirkcudbright in November 1890. The autoharp found its way from the concert stage to use alongside a mainstay traditional instrument during the course of the ensuing decade. The following photo, taken in the village of Stonehouse, shows a fiddler and autoharper groomed and dressed in the style of that period.

Photograph of a fiddler and an autoharper
Cowper Collection, Stonehouse

The noteworthy detail about this autoharp is that it has chord bars of different lengths, just as they appear in Lindemann’s second German patent. It is not at all clear that he also manufactured it (as is the case with a surviving exemplar of similar design). But it does demonstrate that his implementation of the damping bars that Zimmermann inadvertently placed in the public domain was also encountered in the competitive British arena.

If we imagine this duo playing in local Stonehouse establishments, one of the likely venues would have been the Cross Keys Inn on Queen Street. That building is still standing but has since been renamed The Backroad Pub, and provides this post’s banner image. The next outing will take us across the water to the Crosskeys Inn outside Belfast, as well as to pubs in Cork and Dublin. Autoharp players participated in traditional music sessions at all of them in the 1960s.

Subscribe to this discussion
Notify me by email about
guest
This will be displayed with your comment
This will not be displayed with your comment
Clicking the name displayed with your comment will redirect to this address

0 Comments